The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best Pillow Protectors

You spend about a third of your life with your face pressed into your pillow. That pillow absorbs a lot over time – sweat, drool, facial oils, dead skin cells, dust mites, pollen, and other allergens. That’s why investing in a quality pillow protector is so important.

A good pillow protector acts as a barrier against all those particles to keep your pillow clean and extend its lifespan. If you suffer from allergies or asthma, sleep hot, or just want to protect your pillow from dirt and stains, then a protector is a must.

In this guide, we’ll review the top-rated pillow protectors available on Amazon, discuss how to choose the right one for your needs, provide a buying guide to key factors like materials and special features, and answer frequently asked questions. Let’s get started!

Overview of the Best Pillow Protectors on Amazon

Based on in-depth research and analysis of reviews, these five pillow protectors stand out as the top-rated options on Amazon:

Below we’ll delve into detailed reviews for each of these top pillow protectors so you can determine which one best fits your needs and preferences. Let’s get to the reviews!

In-Depth Reviews of the Top 5 Pillow Protectors on Amazon

#1 Saferest Premium Hypoallergenic Pillow Protector

With over 16,000 reviews and a 4.5-star overall rating, the Saferest Premium pillow protector is a top choice for keeping your pillow fresh and clean.

Materials: Cotton terry fabric top, waterproof membrane backing

Sizes: Standard, Queen, King

Key Features:

• Cotton terry surface is soft and absorbent
• Waterproof backing prevents sweat and fluids from penetrating
• Fully enclosed zipper
• Hypoallergenic and protects against dust mites
• OEKO-TEX certified

Price: $$19.99

Pros:

• Very soft and comfortable cotton layer
• Provides full waterproofing and allergen protection
• Backed by 10-year warranty
• Safe hypoallergenic materials
• Available in all standard sizes

Cons:

• Can make pillow feel warmer
• Not as cooling as other materials like bamboo

This protector gets rave reviews for its soft cotton surface, full protection from liquids and allergens, and durable construction. Most found it offered noticeable improvements in their sleep quality by protecting against irritants. Those prone to night sweats said it completely protected their pillows. Some felt the material retained more heat than desired.

Best for: This is an ideal pillow protector choice for allergy sufferers or anyone wanting full protection with a comfortable cotton surface.

Also Check Out: Kid’s Music by Plooshi

#2 Plixio Bamboo Pillow Protector

For a super soft, cooling feel, Plixio’s bamboo pillow protector is a top choice with over 700 reviews.

Materials: 40% bamboo-derived viscose, 60% polyester

Sizes: Standard, Queen, King

Key Features:

• Ultra-soft bamboo viscose cover
• Cooling properties help regulate temperature
• Hypoallergenic and resistant to dust mites
• Zipper closure
• Machine washable

Price: $$15.99

Pros:

• Exceptionally soft, smooth feel
• Promotes cooling and airflow
• Helps reduce allergy symptoms
• Provides protection from fluids and odors
• More affordable than 100% bamboo protectors

Cons:

• Not fully waterproof without TPU backing
• May pill over time
• Only 40% bamboo material

This protector earns consistent praise in reviews for feeling amazingly soft and keeping sleepers cool. Most love the hypoallergenic protection it adds against irritants like dust mites. Many noticed reduced allergy symptoms after use. The lack of full waterproofing was a downside for some.

Best for: This is the top cooling pillow protector option, great for hot sleepers or those who prefer ultra-soft bamboo.

#3 LUCID Premium Hypoallergenic Pillow Protector

With over 14,000 reviews and a 4.4-star rating, LUCID’s hypoallergenic protector is a budget-friendly bestseller.

Materials: Polyester top, waterproof TPU backing

Sizes: Standard, Queen, King

Key Features:

• Soft polyester surface
• Waterproof TPU backing prevents liquid penetration
• Vinyl-free construction
• Fully enclosed zipper
• OEKO-TEX certified materials

Price: $$12.99

Pros:

• Very affordable price point
• Provides full waterproofing protection
• Helps reduce dust mites and allergens
• Noiseless TPU backing unlike vinyl
• Available in all standard sizes

Cons:

• Polyester isn’t as breathable as cotton or bamboo
• Some found TPU backing made pillows sleep warm

This protector earns praise for its budget-friendly price with impressive waterproofing abilities. Most say the vinyl-free TPU backing kept pillows completely dry without crinkling noises. Some wished the surface fabric was more cooling and breathable. Overall, it’s a great choice if your top priorities are affordability and reliable waterproofing.

Best for: This is the best pillow protector option under $15, great for value seekers who still want protection.

#4 Allersoft 100% Cotton Pillow Protector

For those wanting an all-natural protector, Allersoft’s 100% cotton option is a top choice with almost 9,000 reviews.

Material: 100% cotton

Sizes: Standard, Queen, King

Key Features:

• Constructed using natural, breathable cotton
• Provides protection from dust mites, pollen, pet dander
• Naturally hypoallergenic
• Envelope closure
• Machine washable

Price: $$17.99

Pros:

• Soft, cooling 100% cotton cover
• Chemical-free natural cotton material
• Helps reduce allergens in your sleep environment
• Allows airflow to keep pillow surface cooler
• Affordable for 100% cotton construction

Cons:

• Not fully waterproof without backing layer
• Needs replacing more often than some materials

People love this protector for providing allergen and irritant protection using nothing but ultra-breathable cotton. Many allergy sufferers experienced less sneezing, congestion, and other symptoms after use. Others wished it had a waterproof layer as well.

Best for: This is the top 100% natural cotton protector, great for anyone who wants chemical-free bedding.

#5 Hospitology Hypoallergenic Quilted Pillow Protector

For those wanting the cozy feel of a quilted protector, Hospitology’s premium protector has over 3,000 reviews.

Material: Woven polyester top, waterproof vinyl backing

Sizes: Standard, Queen, King

Key Features:

• Quilted polyester sleep surface
• Waterproof backing repels fluids and allergens
• Zipper closure for easy on and off
• Noiseless vinyl backing
• OEKO-TEX certified

Price: $$15.99

Pros:

• Quilted surface is soft and cushiony
• Full protection from liquids and particles
• Reduces irritants for allergy sufferers
• More durable woven polyester layer
• Affordable pricing

Cons:

• Polyester retains more heat than natural fabrics
• Vinyl backing can crinkle over time

This protector stands out for its cozy quilted surface and reliable waterproofing. People mention this protector helps them sleep cooler by absorbing night sweat unlike cheaper versions. Some found the vinyl backing made noise with use but overall reviews are very positive.

Best for: This is ideal for those wanting the plush feel of a quilted protector with the added benefit of waterproofing.

How to Choose the Right Pillow Protector

Now that you know the top options, let’s go over the key factors to consider when picking out a pillow protector:

Determine Your Reason for Needing a Protector

Your specific reason for using a protector can help guide your choice:

• Allergies: Prioritize hypoallergenic materials like cotton, bamboo, polyester and waterproof barriers. Look for dust mite and allergen resistance.
• Night sweats/drooling: Choose a waterproof protector with absorbent fabric like cotton or bamboo. This prevents liquids from soaking through.
• Acne/skin protection: Opt for cotton or bamboo which don’t irritate skin. Look for antimicrobial properties to fight bacteria.
• Children/Pets: Seek out waterproofing and stain resistance. Durable, washable fabrics are ideal.
• General use: Any protector will help extend the pillow’s lifespan by protecting from oils, sweat and dirt.

Pick the Correct Size for Your Pillow

It’s important to choose the right size protector for optimal coverage:

• Standard: Fits most pillows up to 20” x 26”
• Queen: For larger pillows around 20” x 30”
• King: For extra large pillows up to 20” x 36”
• Body: For extra long body pillows up to 20” x 54”

Measure your pillow to ensure a secure fit. The protector should be at least 2 inches larger than the pillow itself.

Material and Special Features

Consider what materials and added features suit your preferences:

• Material: Cotton, bamboo, polyester or a blend. Assess cooling, softness, waterproof needs.
• Waterproofing: Ideal for protection from fluids and incontinence. Vinyl or TPU backing offers this.
• Antimicrobial: Look for bamboo or silver infused fabrics that fight bacteria. Ideal for acne-prone skin.
• Cooling: Bamboo, eucalyptus, and phase change materials help sleep cooler.
• Odor/Stain Protection: Charcoal infused fabrics prevent odors. Stain-resistant treatments add protection.
• Allergen Resistance: Most protectors guard against dust mites, pollen, pet dander. Seek “hypoallergenic” labels.

Prioritize features that address your specific sleep concerns like overheating, allergies, or incontinence protection.

Closure Style

Most protectors use one of these closure styles:

• Zipper: Provides a secure, snug fit that fully encases the pillow. Easy to remove covers for washing.
• Envelope: A fold-over opening like an envelope. Quick to put on but less secure fit.
• Elastic: Stretches over all sides of the pillow. Easy to apply but can shift during sleep.

Zippered protectors are usually preferred for their tighter, customized fit and secure closure.

Price Considerations

Expect to spend $15-30 for most quality pillow protectors. Key factors impacting price:

$15-20: Polyester or cotton protectors, standard sizes.

$20-30: Natural fabrics like bamboo or eucalyptus, special features like cooling or waterproof layers, larger sizes.

$30+: 100% natural materials like organic bamboo or silk, chemical free.

While you can find very cheap protectors for under $10, they are less likely to hold up over time. Invest in the best quality you can afford.

Important Certifications

These certifications indicate safety and quality:

• OEKO-TEX – Verifies no harmful substances were used.
• GREENGUARD Gold – Strict standards for low emissions.
• Standard 100 by OEKO-TEX – Ensures materials are free of contaminants.

Pillow protectors should meet safety standards and limit your exposure to potentially harmful chemicals.

Pillow Protector Buying Guide

Here is a detailed breakdown of what to look for when shopping for a pillow protector:

Types of Fill Materials

The outer shell fabric impacts the protector’s properties:

Cotton: Natural fiber that feels soft and breathable. Moisture-wicking and temperature regulating. Machine washable. More expensive but long-lasting.

Polyester: Widely available synthetic fiber. Affordable option. Durable and wrinkle-resistant. Can sleep warmer than cotton.

Bamboo: Eco-friendly material made from bamboo pulp. Very soft, moisture-wicking and antimicrobial. Luxurious feel. More expensive.

Tencel: Fabric made of wood pulp. Extremely soft, cool, and absorbent. Resists microbes. Costs more but great for hot sleepers.

Eucalyptus: Made of eucalyptus wood pulp. Temperature regulating, soft, breathable. Naturally antimicrobial. Slightly pricier.

Silk: Ultra-luxurious natural protein fiber. Very smooth, breathable and moisture-wicking. Anti-microbial properties. Most expensive option.

Consider any skin sensitivities, tendency to sleep hot, and budget to select the ideal fabric. Cotton, bamboo and Tencel offer the best cooling properties.

Waterproof Backings

Some protectors contain an added barrier layer to prevent liquid penetration:

Vinyl: The most common waterproof backing. Resembles plastic and can make noise. Not as breathable. Budget option.

TPU: A vinyl-free, noiseless alternative for waterproofing. Allows more airflow. More expensive.

Membrane: Ultra-thin layer like Gore-Tex that blocks moisture while allowing airflow. Most breathable and effective option.

If you suffer from incontinence, night sweats, or other moisture issues, choose a protector with the appropriate waterproof backing material.

Special Features

Look for these added features to suit your specific concerns:

Hypoallergenic: Helps reduce allergens like dust mites, mold, pollen. Ideal for allergy sufferers.

Cooling: Technologies like gel-infused memory foam, temperature regulating materials and air channels help prevent heat buildup.

Antimicrobial: Bamboo, tea tree oils and silver fibers fight bacteria growth to combat acne, odors and allergies.

Eco-friendly: Made of natural, organic materials in a sustainable way. No harmful chemicals.

Odor/Stain Protection: Charcoal particles, citrus extracts and phase change materials help prevent odors. Stain-resistant Teflon-like coatings guard against fluids.

See which features best address your sleep concerns like overheating, allergies, or skin protection to improve your comfort.

Closure Types

Secure closure ensures full encasement and no shifting:

• Zipper: Provides snug, adjustable fit. Easy to remove cover. More expensive.
• Envelope: Folded opening like an envelope. Prone to shifting around. Budget-friendly.
• Elastic: Stretches around pillow. Easy to apply but can move during sleep.

Zippered protectors tend to be preferred for their customizable fit and security keeping the protector in place.

Hypoallergenic Properties

Those with allergies benefit from protectors that guard against:

• Dust mites – Microscopic bugs that feed on skin cells. A main trigger for dust allergies.
• Mold – Musty allergen that can grow in pillows due to moisture.
• Pet dander – Microscopic flakes of skin shed by cats, dogs, rodents, birds etc. Major source of pet allergies.
• Pollen – Airborne allergen from flowering plants. Easily sticks to bedding.

“Hypoallergenic” protectors create a barrier against these common allergy triggers using tightly woven, high-thread count fabrics.

Odor Protection

Sweat, drool, microbes, and environmental odors can build up in pillows. These features help combat odors:

• Antimicrobial fabrics – Silver fibers, bamboo, tea tree prevent microbial odors.
• Activated charcoal – Charcoal particles neutralize odors and gases.
• Citrus extracts – Natural oils from plants like orange, eucalyptus, and lemongrass smell fresh.
• Moisture-wicking fabrics – Quickly disperse sweat before odor-causing bacteria grow.

Odor protection maintains a fresh, clean smelling pillow between washings.

Stain Resistance

Stains happen – whether from nighttime drool, makeup residue, or spills. Stain-resistant finishes help guard pillows:

• Teflon or Scotchgard – Seal fabric with a liquid repellent finish.
• Nanotechnology – Nano-scale coatings make fabric impervious to liquids.
• Tighter weaves – Dense, high-thread count fabrics block stains.

Certifications to Look For

These certifications indicate quality materials and manufacturing:

• OEKO-TEX Standard 100 – Confirms textiles meet safety benchmarks and are free of harmful substances.
• GOTS Organic Certified Cotton – Verifies cotton is organic and sustainably produced without chemicals.
• GREENGUARD Gold – Products must meet strict standards for low chemical emissions to achieve this.
• CertiPUR-US – Certifies flexible polyurethane foams are made without PBDEs, TDCPP, or TCEP (“Tris”) flame retardants, mercury, lead, and other heavy metals, formaldehyde, and phthalates regulated by the Consumer Product Safety Commission.
• STANDARD 100 by OEKO-TEX – Certifies textiles meet stringent limits for chemical residues and are high quality.

Look for 1-2 of these respected certifications to ensure safety and quality construction.

Price Range

Plan to spend:

• $10-$20 – Basic polyester or cotton protectors without special features.
• $20-$30 – Natural fabrics like bamboo or added layers like waterproof backing.
• $30+ – Luxury materials like silk, organic cotton, or high-end performance tech.

On the low end, some vinyl protectors cost under $10 but these tend not to hold up over time or breathe well. Expect to invest $15+ for decent quality, especially if you want special features.

Warranties

A 1-2 year warranty is standard. Longer warranties indicate durability:

• 90 days – Basic polyester protectors.
• 1 year – Average for most protectors.
• 2-5 years – Better materials stand up longer without defects.
• 10 years – Indicates premium quality construction and materials.

Look for at least a 1 year warranty. The higher priced the protector, the longer the warranty should be for peace of mind.

FAQs About Pillow Protectors

Do you still have some questions about using pillow protectors? Here are answers to common queries:

How often should you replace a pillow protector?

Plan on replacing your pillow protector every 6-12 months. Less if you notice yellowing, tearing, or broken zippers. Some last 2-3 years if properly cared for.

Do you need a protector if you use a pillowcase?

While a pillowcase prevents visible stains, it doesn’t block dust mites, allergens, body oils, and microbes from penetrating the pillow. A protector acts as a complete barrier.

Can you use a pillow protector with a mattress topper?

Yes, pillow protectors work fine with toppers. Choose a slightly larger size protector to fit over your pillow with the topper on.

How do you wash a pillow protector?

Check label instructions but most can be machine washed on warm and tumble dried on low. Avoid bleach and fabric softener.

When is it time to replace your pillow protector?

Replace if it’s over a year old, has yellowed, ripped, broken zipper, strange odors that won’t wash out, or is visibly stained.

Do pillow protectors reduce allergy symptoms?

Yes, good protectors act as a barrier against common allergens like dust mites and pet dander. This helps reduce exposure to those irritants.

Do you need pillow protector for latex or memory foam pillows?

Yes, protectors will still help shield any pillow material from body oils, dead skin, and microbes that degrade them over time.

Conclusion

We hope this guide has simplified your search for the perfect pillow protector. The right protector helps your pillow stay fresh and clean, extend its usable lifespan, prevent allergens, and even improve your overall sleep comfort. Look for a snug fitting, breathable protector with features that address your specific issues like night sweats, allergies or acne. Protect your investment and health by shielding your pillow with a quality protector.

Originally posted on September 19, 2023 @ 1:14 am

Previous

Best Firm Pillows for Proper Neck Support and Spinal Alignment

Next

Best Mattresses for Scoliosis Support and Pain Relief

Dr. Barry Jarvis

Dr. Barry Jarvis is a renowned sleep specialist, dedicating their illustrious career to the intricate world of sleep medicine. Holding a medical degree from a prestigious institution, Dr. Jarvis has cultivated a deep understanding of the complex mechanisms that govern sleep and its pivotal role in overall health and well-being. With a compassionate approach and a meticulous eye for detail, Dr. Jarvis has helped countless individuals reclaim restful nights and vibrant days. Beyond their clinical expertise, they have contributed to groundbreaking research in sleep medicine, unraveling the mysteries of sleep disorders and pioneering innovative treatments that stand at the forefront of the field.